.
Feedback

Lawsuit Challenges EIR for Albany Beach Restoration

A group has filed a lawsuit that cites potential negative impacts of allowing off-leash dogs, adding parking spaces.

The Environmental Impact Report for restoration of Albany Beach is being challenged by a group that says the EIR fails to consider the impact of off-leash dogs and windsurfers, according to an article in the Oakland Tribune.

A group called Sustainability, Parks, Recycling and Wildlife Defense Fund (SPRAWLDEF) has filed a lawsuit against the East Bay Regional Park District, which manages the state-owned beach property, the Tribune reported today.

The group says that allowing dogs to run off-leash has negative impacts on both wildlife and human park users.

SPRAWLDEF also contends that a proposed parking lot would improve access for boaters and windsurfers, who could potentially damage an area of eel grass, an endangered species.

You may read the complete Tribune article here.

John Rusk January 31, 2013 at 05:25 pm
The dogs were there first. Even before the homeless encampments.
Ross Stapleton-Gray January 31, 2013 at 05:51 pm
http://sprawldef.org/about_us/history__mission_statement
"After Mr. [Norman] LaForce and Mr. [David] Tam conceived the need for advocacy, SPRAWLDEF was incorporated in 2004 with Steve Lautze joining them as one of the three founding members of SPRAWLDEF.
Paul Kamen January 31, 2013 at 06:01 pm
You can read the full text of the filing on the CDAWGS website, http://www.cdawgs.org.
It seems calculated to alienate everyone. By siding with Golden Gate Fields in opposition to completing the missing link in the Bay Trail, SPRAWLDEF positions itself against hikers and bicyclists. If successful, the suit will block a project that provides ADA access to the shoreline, improved access for kayaks and kiteboards, expansion and protection of the dune habitat, and better parking for everyone. But the big issue is dog play on the sand and in the water. SPRAWLDEF's main objection appears to be that the Park District wisely opts not to impose draconian measures to shut down the most popular use of the Districts most densely-used park.
Henry Stimson January 31, 2013 at 06:11 pm
SPRAWLDEF, Mr. LaForce, etc have negative impacts on windsurfers, dog owners, boaters and the taxpayers who have to pay for these self-important delay-tactic lawsuits.
Who speaks for them in this attempt to force one-sided change?
Paul Kamen February 1, 2013 at 02:54 am
Only one comment on this issue since 11:30 this morning?
My comment appears to be "pending approval," which seems strange. Let's pick up the conversation over on Berkeleyside if we no longer have access to an open discussion here on the Patch.
Paul Kamen February 1, 2013 at 05:36 pm
I was at a CESP Board meeting a couple of months ago (they are open to the public) at which Norman LaForce tried to get CESP to oppose the project. Much to their credit, CESP declined.
Deena Brown February 2, 2013 at 09:15 pm
A large section of the Albany bulb, has been fenced off for burrowing owls for the past 3 years or so. Has anyone ever seen a borrowing owl in that area? I wonder at the necessity of protecting this small stretch of beach in Albany from people and dogs in favor of eel grass. This is a little beach that has always been enjoyed by Albany families (including their wading kids and dogs). If it is made part of the Bay Trail, that would be wonderful. I love the outsider art and the botanical invasion of what was, after all, was construction materials dump site. I think a little freedom at the bulb is a cherished tradition for many families.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Albany Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Amy Smolens June 7, 2013 at 02:57 pm
Hi there - This doesn't seem like an appropriate announcement for Albany or Berkeley Patch. 1) theRead More category is Announcements/Around Town and these events are all in Marin 2) Patch's "Terms of Use" say "You may use this Service solely for personal and non-commercial purposes. That is to say: You can’t use the Service to make a living unless you enter into a separate agreement with us that says you can." This is clearly solely a commercial venture, not a neighbor of ours or local organization providing a community service and charging for the service. 3) I went to the Novato website and saw this listing: "Ettiquette (sic) Series for Kids - 17737 Ages: 7 Years to 11 Years - Residents $150.00 - Non-residents $163.00" 4) These items push our items of local interest down and out of sight. Especially now that there is no box indicating the stories with the most recent comments, as there used to be on the Patch front page, out of sight does mean out of mind. Charles, what are your thoughts here? Thanks.
angie allison June 7, 2013 at 03:45 pm
Hi Amy, Thank you for letting me know and I understand! Angie
Mechanics from Street Level Cycles tune up bikes at the Albany Arts & Green Festival. Photo courtesy Matt McHugh
Lin B. June 6, 2013 at 11:29 am
I've been waiting for the right time to donate my son's old bike he used in middle/high school. It'sRead More been hanging on hooks in the garage and this seems like a great time to give it up!
christopher papazoglow June 7, 2013 at 10:30 am
Can you please post their hours / days of operation ? As i recall, they're only open afternoons aRead More few days a week, and it won't do to just leave donations outside ( they'll be scavenged ). And i was not able to find the info online.
AS&R - Albany Strollers & Rollers June 7, 2013 at 11:20 am
Thanks, Christopher. Open Community Hours are Friday, Saturday, Sunday 12-6pm so anytime those daysRead More are definitely fine. They're there (84 Bolivar Drive - Aquatic Park) most of the day Wednesdays and Thursdays for Youth Classes and the doors are locked. I just spoke to Amber Rich and she asked you to call them at 510 644 2577 and let them know what time is good for you and they will be sure to be there. Thanks for your generosity!
Dover June 5, 2013 at 02:47 pm
Thanks for the update but I am worried. This is very distressing. How will Eric and Tarina be ableRead More to afford their annual lengthy hipster vacation if they have to cough up lawyer fees? I am sure they were expecting that UCB (aka the rest of us) would pay Mr. Siegel's bill. Now they may have to resort to staying home and eating Top Ramen out of their charming and cheerful "made in Asia by small children but they're not slaving for 14 hours a day in front of our faces so we don't care" ceramic bowls. Oh noes! Bad, bad, very, very bad news.
Charles Burress (Editor) June 5, 2013 at 03:06 pm
David, thanks for the alert to the judge's decision.